The SEC is re-examining one of the most important disclosures companies provide – Management’s Discussion and Analysis, or MD&A. I’ve read lots of MD&As in my time, and to be completely candid, many of them – or at least too many of them – are poor.
There are lots of ways in which MD&As are poor, but my principal complaints are as follows:
- They don’t provide the “A” in MD&A – the analysis. Sales are up? Great! Why were they up? Well, that’s anyone’s guess. “Increased market acceptance of our product.” Also great, but does “greater acceptance” mean that more units sold? That customers were willing to pay more for each unit, so the company raised the price? That the company expanded the markets in which the product is sold? Beats me.
- Instead of discussing the “why’s,” companies do a cut and paste of key line items in their financial statements, sometimes with a “Percentage Change” column, indicating how much each line in, say, the P&L changed from period to period. In other words, they’re doing what any reader can do, which is precisely what prior SEC glosses on MD&A disclosure have said not to do. And then they copy and paste sections of the notes to financial statements about how revenue is determined. Again, no “why.”
I could rattle off a list of other weaknesses of many MD&As, but let’s move on.Continue Reading Analyze This!


In recent years, the SEC has made a number of incremental changes to make disclosures more effective – not only more meaningful and user-friendly for investors, but also helpful to those of us who prepare disclosures for our companies and clients.
I recently came across an 
As we
As our readers know, I am irritated by Congress’s penchant for naming bills so as to create nifty acronyms. And for including provisions that have nothing to do with the name or the acronym. However, I can better put up with these irritants when the legislation – and SEC regulations implementing the legislation – create a good result.
On February 19, 2019,
Lest you think that the SEC’s focus on the use of non-GAAP financial metrics is so, well, 2018, think again. On December 26, the SEC issued a
As we approach the end of 2018, it’s only natural to look back on some of the year’s events – and some non-events. For my money, one of the most significant non-events was the inauguration of CEO pay ratio disclosure, one of the evil spawn of Dodd-Frank.
Since the beginning of this month (July 2018), the SEC has brought two enforcement cases involving perquisites disclosure – one involving Dow Chemical, and one involving Energy XXI. As my estimable friend Broc Romanek noted in a